This is another of the Newbery Honor books from last year. I didn't like it as well as Red White and Whole (see previous review). It is well written, and the characters are sympathetic, but there are a lot of controversial ideas here. (spoiler alert). In the end, the ghost leads Bug to discover that she is transgender. I read the book George, and in that book, the child had believed he was really a she for a long time and the book was about getting the courage to tell someone how she felt. In this book, however, the only evidence that Bug has that she is a he, is that he isn't interested in dresses and makeup and giggling about boys. I don't know if it is a great message that if you are not a girly girl, you aren't a girl at all. There are plenty of girls who don't like makeup or dresses, but are still girls. Also, Bug makes the discovery that she is transgender soon after the death of the Uncle, during a family financial crisis, and right before starting middle school. I don't think an 12-year-old, who hasn't even started puberty yet, should be making those kinds of decisions in the middle of emotional crisis. Finally, the book portrayed Bug's decision to come out as transgender as the solution to all his problems. Everyone in his life accepts his decision without drama or trauma. I don't think that is realistic. I don't see a school of early teenagers, or their teachers, all being that kind and accepting. (2021, 192 p)
Monday, March 28, 2022
Too Bright to See by Kyle Lukoff
Saturday, March 26, 2022
Red White and Whole Rajani LaRocca
This was a Newbery Honor book last year, and totally deserves it. It is beautifully written in free verse; both heartrending and heartwarming at the same time. Even though Reha is dealing with issues around being Indian, her story is about every child growing up and wrestling with how they fit into their family while fitting into the world. I was really impressed with the fact that she has two parents who love her but show it differently. It is pretty rare these days to have functional family life portrayed in children's literature. I am glad the Newbery committee chose a book that is inclusive but not overburdened with a dozen social issues. (2021, 224 p)
Friday, March 25, 2022
Sisters of Neversea by Cynthia Leitich Smith
This book got starred reviews when it came out in 2021. It addresses the problems of racism and sexism in Barrie's classic that have bothered modern readers. I wonder, though, if the author actually read Barrie's Peter and Wendy, or if she just watched the Disney cartoon version. The cartoon version is very un-PC, and so is the book, but if you focus on that you miss what is enchanting about the original Peter Pan. The orginal is about navigating the wonderful and painful path from childhood to adulthood. This book is about regrets and how giving in to escapism leads to corruption and brutality. I can see what the author, who is a Native Amercian, was trying to do, and I think it is something worth doing, but what she ended up with is quite dark and has none of the charm of the original story. I think it could have been possible to get the same message across without Peter being so cold blooded. It was a bit hard for me to get through and I don't think I will be recommending it to anyone. (plus it bothers me that Lily on the cover looks African American instead of Native American) (201, 320 p.)
Wednesday, March 23, 2022
Where I Belong by Heather B. Moore
This is another romance by the author that came to our library at the beginning of the month. It is a sweet and clean romance and I caught myself smiling a lot while I listened to it. As with her other romance that I read, the make-out scenes had a little more heat than I am used to, but they never get past "first base." The two books I read were not "Christian" romances, just clean contemporary romances. I have one of her historical fictions on hold and will report on that when it comes in. (2018, 208 p)
Sunday, March 20, 2022
The Devil and the Dark Water by Stuart Turton
I was excited to see another book written by the same author as The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evalyn Hardcastle, and I enjoyed it a lot. I wasn't quite as impressed by this as I was by Turton's first novel, but I think there are a lot of people that would like it more. The Evalyn Hardcastle book was very complex, but Turton's ability to write characters was amazing. Some people who read it, however, got too bogged down in the complexity. This one is a little more straight forward, and, I think, more accessible, but the characters are not quite as amazing. Don't get me wrong, they are well drawn and complex, and the romance between Sara and Arent is sweet. The plot is also well thought out, though I read a plot summary that ended up being a spoiler, so there was no surprise ending for me. I think most people will find the ending surprising and satisfying. This is an excellent historical mystery that has something for both male and female readers; maybe a good choice of something to listen to together on a long car trip. (full disclosure, I listened to it at 1 1/4 speed, and that worked out fine). (2020, 480 p)
Saturday, March 12, 2022
Shoe Dog by Phil Knight
This is a candid, warts-and-all, memoire that I found totally captivating. It gives the reader a peak into the mind of one of the US's top entrepreures, and also into the world of big corporation intrigue and power struggles. I gained a lot of insight into the process of starting a successful manufacturing business, and was amazed by how often Knight was kind of "shooting from the hip." I appreciate that Knight admits his own weaknesses and shortcomings, especially when it comes to his relations with his family and co-workers. He seems to have realized, in hindsight, that he was a bit of an jerk in his younger years, and regrets it. The unsung hero in his story is his long-suffering wife, Penny, who sticks with him through years of neglect, financial instability, and her husband's mercurial moods. As I was reading this book I couldn't help talking about it with my friends and family, and I am sure I will be recommending it to patrons often in the future. (2016, 400 p.)
Tuesday, March 8, 2022
Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis
I have several books on hold, and needed something to fill the gap until they came in. My daughter recently mentioned that she had reread Mere Christianity a few months ago, so when I came across it while browsing I thought I might do the same. As I read through it, none of it was familiar, so I think I never read it before, though I have heard it quoted pleanty of times. It is a classic, and I found it refreshed my soul. Even though I don't believe in everything Lewis says, especially since I am not a trinitarian, still, I admire his keen whit, his sharp intellect, and his accessible manner. (I must confess as I listened to the narrator, I pictured Anthony Hopkins playing Lewis in Shadowlands, when he is giving his lectures.) Listening to this short book gave me a lot to think about this week and I recommend it to anyone who is a devoted Christian. (227 p. 1952)
Thursday, March 3, 2022
The Last Mile by David Baldacci
It had been a long time since I had read a "masculine" suspense novel, so I decided on this second in the Memory Man series. It is a fun read. There are a few little events that are a bit too coincidental and convenient, but overall it has a well crafted plot with interesting characters. Baldacci includes a little less violence, gore, and sex than other suspense thrillers I have read. There is swearing, but it isn't out of character, and the sexual abuse (which always seems to be an element in this genre) is
off screen and alluded to, instead of described. If you like adult mysteries, I think this is one a couple could enjoy listening to together on a long car trip. (433 p. 2016)